I was not using them (regarding Gears of War and Halo) as examples of competition, but rather games that have risen above the crowd, they are not just 'good', and have accordingly sold many millions of copies.
Looking at other forums (such as here) that post by the moderator seems credible (supposedly the game sold more in Europe than America). But even so, that would be on a console that had sold around 80 million by the game's release. Attachment rate wise it was at around 2.5%. With the current prediction of lifetime sales of the PS3 at around 51 million that would give it 1.275 million copies sold, but that would be if the game was released near the end of the PS3's lifetime, not near the beginning.
From this I still think the game should be in the 1.2-1.4million (120-140DKP) range.
2
I was not using them (regarding Gears of War and Halo) as examples of competition, but rather games that have risen above the crowd, they are not just 'good', and have accordingly sold many millions of copies.
Looking at other forums (such as here) that post by the moderator seems credible (supposedly the game sold more in Europe than America). But even so, that would be on a console that had sold around 80 million by the game's release. Attachment rate wise it was at around 2.5%. With the current prediction of lifetime sales of the PS3 at around 51 million that would give it 1.275 million copies sold, but that would be if the game was released near the end of the PS3's lifetime, not near the beginning.
From this I still think the game should be in the 1.2-1.4million (120-140DKP) range.